Sunday, June 20, 2010

Nurse Romance Stories: Love Secrets 32 - "He Wasn't My Kind of Man"

Earlier this year I posted scans from the cover story of Love Secrets 32, "I Fell For A Commie". The book also contains this 6-page nurse romance story, "He Wasn't My Kind of Man". The scenario is as follows: Alice Daniels is a newly hired private nurse for financier Byron Mapleton. Mapleton's handsome secretary, Michael Lester, is also a recent hire, and he and Alice are quick to team up in their task of surviving old Mapleton's grumpiness. It also looks as though something romantic might develop between Alice and Michael, until Mapleton's no-good son Craig turns up. He starts putting the moves on Alice straight away, which is bad news, because he's not the industrious student his father believes him to be.
Against her better judgment, Alice weakens and goes out with Craig, who likes to spend his father's money liberally, but not in the way his father expects. Alice gets caught up in a romantic whirl with Craig, and it all happens so quickly that Michael has no opportunity to tell Alice he's in love with her until he's about to leave Mapleton's employ. By then Alice is convinced that there's something real between her and Craig.

Craig's reckless gambling ends up getting him in trouble with the mafia. He steals some money from his father to pay his gambling debts, and when old Mapleton finds the dough missing he prefers to blame Michael rather than his son. Alice spills the beans about Craig, who tries to lie his way out of trouble, unsuccessfully. Alice has already realized Craig is a loser who didn't care about her really, and her hopes that Michael might still be interested in her are realized.
As is often the case with these nurse romance stories, the nurse is a proxy for stereotypes of womanhood generally, and in this story she's shown as someone who is easily fooled, easily led by a manipulative male. On the other hand she's principled, and although she went out with Craig knowing Mapleton would disapprove, she fairly quickly concluded that the younger Mapleton's behavior was hugely inappropriate, and she does the right thing in shopping him to his dad. Although she leaps to the righteous Michael's defense, the concluding scenario places her back in the subordinate position to her new man. She's feminine, and delicate in the final analysis, even though she stood up to her boss when he falsely accused Michael. She's definitely the kind of tough but vulnerable flower any respectable, mildly chauvinistic, heterosexual male would like to scoop up and protect, which is what Michael does.

Saturday, June 19, 2010

Nurses At War: Our Fighting Forces 53 - "The Gunner and the Nurse"

This Jan/Feb 1960 issue of DC's Our Fighting Forces (#53) features a great Joe Kubert cover, not included here. The set of scans I have available (not mine) has a defaced cover. The splash page is the same scenario as the cover but redrawn by Ross Andru and Mike Esposito, who are the story artists in this one.
The script is by Robert Kanigher and follows his formula which uses the first half of the story to set the scene and lay the groundwork for the introduction of the main idea. This first section ends with Gunner taking a rest in a trench after some enemy action has been dealt with.
It should be mentioned that Gunner and Sarge are on a Pacific island. Gunner wakes up from his nap to find a gorgeous army nurse looking down at him. She's on a mission to kiss every American hero on the island, and Gunner is about to be a beneficiary of this enterprise when Sarge steps in and whisks the nurse off on a tour of their habitat. Sarge is also berating his subordinate in front of the lady, which frustrates Gunner even more. Suddenly the group is set upon by a couple of enemy troops, and Sarge has to take the responsibility of dealing with them while Gunner protects the nurse. When the skirmish is over it puts Sarge even more in the hero's light, and the nurse plants one of her hero award kisses on him, which winds Gunner up even more.
Sarge utilizes the rest of Nurse Julie's visit to impress her with his battle tales, but when it comes time for her to leave, Gunner is entrusted with the job of taking her back out to the ship. Just as he delivers her on board and is saying farewell, the vessel is struck by an enemy torpedo and they are forced into the lifeboat as the ship starts to sink. Before they can reach safety a Japanese Zero joins the attack and strafes them with its machine guns. Gunner shoots back but is clipped by the Zero's wing on its first pass. As it comes round a second time Gunner opens up and downs the plane, saving Julie's life. When Julie pulls herself back together after her near death experience, she gives Gunner that kiss he's been craving, sending him into a state of bliss.
Some panels stand out, like this one where Gunner takes on the enemy plane.
Julie comes across as a confident, assertive young woman, very feminine but ultimately supportive of male dominance. Although in some ways acting in a liberated fashion, she also willingly makes herself an object of male exploitation. She has a cute, practical, short hairstyle suitable for war in the Pacific, but is still angelic in overall appearance and demeanor.
Some late 50s/early 60s DC Comics depictions of kissing behavior are quite interesting. In this story we've got a nurse who is consciously going around kissing the soldiers, which undoubtedly would have had an uplifting effect on their morale but in a real life situation might have earned her a questionable reputation. An upcoming post on this blog will examine the phenomenon of the kissing booth and kissing fund-raisers, starting with the example presented by Lois Lane 21 (November 1961). But for now, back to Our Fighting Forces 53.
Essentially, in this story the nurse's presence creates a loose, temporary 'family' situation with Julie and Sarge as the couple, and Gunner in the role of something like a teenage boy. Julie respects Sarge for his manly superiority, justified by his acts of heroism, which Gunner is aching to emulate and finally gets the chance to when he protects the nurse. He's become a man, and Julie will petition the Sarge on his behalf to allow him to engage in 'grown up' activities - going on patrol, much as a mother in a traditional nuclear family might persuade her husband that their son is now ready to drive. Because it's not actually a family, Julie is free to reward Gunner with the adult privilege of a sexy kiss, now that he's proved he's a man.

The image of nurses presented by this story includes that of the sexy nurse, toned down for code approved comics and because DC generally provided respectable reading material appropriate for a younger audience in the Silver Age. So although it's a mild example, nevertheless Julie appears as beautiful, desirable, and importantly for this stereotype, available, and even promiscuous, albeit in this fairly muted way. She's there for men to enjoy. This can be a particularly damaging popular image of nurses and nursing which, in the worst of instances, can encourage sexual harassment and assault of female nurses by male patients and medical staff. It may also have contributed significantly to the lowering of the nurse's professional status in the eyes of the public, something the profession has long fought to counteract with stereotype disconfirming media campaigns. No harm was intended with this story, of course. It was simply using a popular theme from the time -American soldiers loved having nurses around - and surely there were few other western women for them to interact with when they were deployed. I think it's no coincidence that the great war veteran comic book writers and artists reverentially portray nurses in a variety of ways in their stories. I can't think of any examples where nurses are disrespectfully portrayed by them - Jack Kirby's and Bob Kanigher's nurses seem to always be the self-sacrificing angels, and Nurse Julie in this story is also that primarily. She's sacrificing her own safety to see to the well-being of the fighting men. This story does incorporate a little of that sexy nurse image as well, however, although nothing like the way Stan Lee used that image for Nellie the Nurse, the subject of some upcoming posts right here on Out Of This World.

Friday, June 18, 2010

Visual Innuendo: The Lighthouse Cover

The cover of Lovers' Lane 11, published by Lev Gleason, could possibly exemplify an archetypal lighthouse cover because of its reduction to the basic elements, even though it departs somewhat from the usual scenario where such an object is utilized in romance comics. In the early 1950s when, despite the lack of the Comics Code, direct mention of sex in mass media for the general public was taboo, such matters could be inferred through the use of symbols. In the case of this cover, the symbolism helps explain the apparently incongruous use of a lighthouse in what appears to be a picture frame, and a very unusually shaped one at that, given the subject matter. It could be a window, again of a very unusual shape. So what we see here is a young woman preparing for her wedding, lost in meditation on the privileges she will enjoy that night with her legally wedded husband. Hence the beaming smile - not long to wait! The solid, upright lighthouse represents the subject of her reverie, encircled by a pristine, gilt-edged orifice. The older woman assisting with the bride-to-be's preparation is perhaps her grandmother, and as evidenced by the direction of her gaze and the look on her face, she remembers fondly her own earliest encounter with manhood, as she views the same scene but through the veil, representative of the mists of time. More typically, a lighthouse cover involves a couple embracing, usually kissing, in a coastal location or on board a vessel, with the building somewhere in the background, emphasizing the passionate arousal engendered by the encounter. Within the confines of romance comics, then, the lighthouse structure, and its association with the characters and plot, was used as an indirect reference to what older readers would have been able to interpret as 'off-screen' or otherwise hidden events. It was a more innocent time. I wonder what the average person from the early 1950s would think of the degeneracy of modern society's explicit norms.

True Nurse Stories: New Heroic Comics 44 - "Nurse Without Fear"

This is a short, two page, true life story of a heroic nurse, Esther McElveen, who gave her life making sure patients were safe after their sanatorium caught fire in South Carolina. The story, published in 1947, speaks for itself, but of additional note is that it is an early example of the work of none other than Alex Toth.
The book has an interesting painted cover, but Toth's interior artwork is the main attraction (there are two stories by him). Here's the nurse story:
The image of nurses presented by this short true story is that of the self-sacrificing angel. We see beautiful, feminine nurses dedicated to the care of their patients, with one who sacrificed her life for their sake.

Wednesday, June 16, 2010

Nurse Romance Stories: Boy Meets Girl 12 - "Prescription for a Broken Heart"

Lev Gleason only published two romance titles. This one, Boy Meets Girl, which became Boy Loves Girl in July 1952, and Lover's Lane. The examples I have from each series suggest that the rest are worth seeking out - they are nice books, with decent artwork and not too shabby stories. Issue 12, the original cover painting of which should be hanging in the Met, IMO, has a great painted cover, and a nurse romance story that initially looked to me like it was maybe drawn by a young Gil Kane. Following Spectergirl's observation that it was signed 'Kid', a little research on the Grand comics Database indicates that the art is probably by Fred Kida, also known as 'The Kid', and who did sign some of his work 'Kid'. Lydexicuss did a feature on Kida's work on Ringo Kid for Atlas in the 1950s, so it's possible to compare this piece with those stories. Admittedly these westerns are from a different genre and possibly a little later, but what do you think?

http://tencentdreams.blogspot.com/2009/11/fred-kida-ringo-kid-week.html

It's also one of those romance stories where you really get your money's worth in terms of reading. "Prescription for a Broken Heart" quickly sets the scene, with Staff Nurse Marcia fending off marriage proposals and a job offer as his office nurse from Dr. Eric Anders. It seems Marcia's hesitancy to pursue marriage with Eric, or with older doctor, Frank Graham, revolves around her being able to feel that she would be needed by her husband in his climb "up the ladder". Marcia's friend Nora thinks Graham would be Marcia's better option, because he's already established.
Dates with Frank are apparently typically interrupted by emergency calls. But Marcia's okay with that, because Frank's psychological dependence on Marcia gives her the feeling of being useful. I guess we have co-dependency here, but of a slightly unhealthy kind. Frank's been overdoing it, though, and not getting enough sleep. As a result, he has a breakdown during an operation, and has to ask Anders, who is assisting, to take over. Frank is so out of it that he even accidentally calls Anders 'Andrews'. Dr. Anders completes the operation successfully. Frank, however, is now hospitalized himself, with Marcia nursing at his bedside. He pops the question he's been waiting to ask her, but Marcia wants to wait until he's recovered before she answers. Eric, however, acts as if the wedding between Frank and Marcia is now a foregone conclusion, and wishes them luck.
Then comes a twist of fate that will lay everybody's cards on the table. Marcia contracts a serious, contagious disease, and has to go into isolation. Frank declines the opportunity to attend, fearing that he will contract the disease himself. Marcia, shocked, realizes Frank was not the man she had assumed he was. Eric, on the other hand, jumps at the chance to treat Marcia, and guides her recovery. Nora revises the advice she gave Marcia previously, and now advocates for Eric. When flowers arrive from Frank, Marcia's only inclination is to reject them, and Eric agrees as they might cause an allergic reaction. It turns out that Eric is gentle as well as tough and determined, and now Marcia gets to see this other side of his personality. I love panels 3 and 4 on the last page, with Nora walking past and commenting as the two lovers kiss.
Nurses, according to this story: they're pretty, young, white women who work in hospitals at the patient's bedside. While they are invested in their work, a component of their being a nurse is the opportunity the job presents for romance with doctors, and ultimately marriage with one.

Tuesday, June 15, 2010

Nurse Romance Stories: Dream Book of Romance 6 - "Torn by Temptation"

Magazine Enterprises published a total of 7 romance comics, and this is one of them. Dream Book of Romance 6 (April-June 1954) boasts a Marlon Brando photo cover and interior artwork by Bob Powell, Fred Guardineer, and this nurse romance story by Frank Bolle. The tale starts with engaged couple, Nurse Ann Barton (possibly a distant relative of Clara Barton, but we're left to speculate here) and Dr. Ted Stevens, who must make do with the occasional passionate clinch in the doctor's office during a very busy work schedule that doesn't permit them time to go out together. Ted is steadfast in his dedication to both his job and his future marriage to Ann, and just needs to finish his residency so that they are in a position to wed. Ann, however, is wavering. She pines for excitement and partying, and loses patience with Ted, failing to keep hold of the bigger picture and see how the sacrifice in the short term will reap rewards in their relationship in the future. In her weakened state, she falls prey to the suggestions of handsome outpatient Fred Daniels.
Ann succumbs and goes out with Fred, and their date ends with a dreamy kiss that spells danger for her relationship with Ted.
Ted's no fool, and has observed what's going on with Ann, yet he's unable to talk sense into her. Instead she gets into party mode with Fred. When Ted tells her he wants her to stop seeing Fred, she returns Ted's ring and the engagement is off. But by now the veneer over Fred's real character is wearing thin, and some of the truth is emerging. He likes having Ann around as eye candy for his business clients. Plus there's no proposal in sight. Meanwhile her constant partying is making Ann slip up at work, something that won't be tolerated in the hospital where lives are at stake.
Then reality hits home. On their way to a meeting with one of Fred's important clients, Ann sees a road accident in which people are badly hurt. Her instincts as a nurse kick in and she provides crucial care for the crash victims while they wait for the ambulance. Fred, however, thought his meeting was more important, and when Ann refuses to accompany him, because she wants to tend to the injured, he dumps her, but as far as Ann is concerned, it's good riddance! The injured people eventually end up at the hospital, where Ted treats them, but they wouldn't have made it without Ann's intervention. Ted is full of admiration for Ann's willingness to stay and care for the injured, and she's had her eyes opened after Fred so selfishly drove off - a Good Samaritan he ain't. Ted never let go of his love for Ann, and now a wiser woman, she's immediately accepted back by him. Lucky girl! Hopefully she won't be so dumb in the future. A good partner is worth waiting for. Lesson learned.
Some nice panels in this story. The image of nurses and nursing in this one includes the idea that nursing is boring work, that nurses are forced to work long, irregular hours, and that nurses get romantically involved with doctors and patients. Ann's self-sacrificing angel identity was brought out when she was faced with injured people from the car crash who needed help. Ann did say she loved her work, which is another positive.

Monday, June 14, 2010

Nurse Romance Stories: Love At First Sight 7 - "The Man I Couldn't Have"

Ace romance comics, judging from those in my collection, are physically relatively narrow compared to those of other companies, St. John for example. They also seem to go for these painted portrait covers, but not exclusively. The nurse romance story in issue 7, "The Man I Couldn't Have", while set in a hospital, follows one particular romance story formula - that of the two future couples with partners destined for each other but mixed up in the beginning. The tale starts with Nurse Roa Kent tending to accident victim Andy Hunter. Andy feels bad about his secretary, Serena Barbour, also injured in the accident. She was only in the car because he had asked her to drive home with him. It's not indicated exactly what their relationship had been before their hospitalization, but Andy is quick to propose, and Serena accepts. Roa finds herself somewhat disturbed by this event, and as time goes by she starts to realize she has feelings for Andy. When he asks her to be his private nurse once he's discharged, she declines, even though her heart is all for it. She doesn't want to come between Andy and his betrothed. Despite now being engaged to Serena, however, Andy starts making overtures to Roa - what's going on???
Andy blurts it out - he's in love with Roa. But Roa's own personal code of ethics will not let her involve herself with Andy and hurt Serena. She hands Andy's case over to another nurse. Then Andy's Doctor, Wentworth, starts pushing Roa for a date, despite her protestations that nurses dating doctors are frowned upon by the hospital authorities. Andy, however, assumes that Roa's brush off results from her being romantically involved with Wentworth. Roa tries to make it clear that Andy now has a responsibility to Serena, to whom he is engaged. Serena also now is disabled, making it doubly important to Roa that she not cause the injured woman any further grief. Yet on her date with Ned Wentworth she can't get Andy off her mind, and Ned notices. He realizes he's not going to make any progress with Roa. She's too smitten with Andy.
To quieten Andy's ardor, Roa tells him she engaged to Ned. In her thoughts we see her one hundred percent determined not to steal a disabled woman's fiancee. This was a time when people knew right from wrong and some were prepared to suffer rather than take the wrong path. Andy discharges himself from the hospital, and for the next week Roa hears nothing from Ned, until she's called to assist in Serena's surgery, which is successful. The plot gets really sudsy here, with Andy not quite given the opportunity to state his love for Serena, and Serena apologizing for having kissed Ned out of gratitude for being able to walk normally again. There's a lot of unspoken feelings, but they're all welling to the surface for the finale to this romance tale. In the evening Ned and Roa go dancing and the Doctor gives it one last shot and again asks Roa to marry him.
What Roa doesn't know is that Ned Wentworth has set up a situation that is going to bring everything out into the open. He's already cured Serena to reduce Roa's potential feelings of guilt should she end up with Andy, but he has a further strategy up his sleeve. Knowing that Andy is in love with Roa and that he will leap to her defense, he asks Roa to slap him in the face as if he'd made an improper suggestion. Serena's disgust with Andy's conduct and her sympathy towards Ned is also apparently something the Doctor had predicted. He's read the characters well. There's a double wedding, and Roa can love her man free of guilt.
Although the prevailing opinion is that romance comics are dead because these kinds of stories don't reflect today's reality, I'm starting to challenge that viewpoint in my own mind. While the plots of these romance stories appear contrived, the feelings people have, the emotional turmoil that some go through in their relationships, or their search for love, are not so unreal. Today they may take on a new face, but they're still the subject of romantic movies, t.v. shows, novels, and the anguished confidential talks of people of all ages going through relationships. Without it, in fact, we might completely lose the human condition. We might as well be machines with no feelings. Maybe that's why these old romance books are so fascinating, even though we quip about their cheesiness. On some level perhaps we're connecting with an essential truth about ourselves as human beings. Not for everybody, obviously, although I think that if more people were exposed to romance comics there would be a revival of interest. It certainly isn't true that the genre is dead. Romance manga abound. Could a revival of the American romance comic book be nearer than we think!?

The image of nurses presented by this story adheres to the self-sacrificing angel idea. Roa doesn't want to break the hospital 'rules' about nurse-doctor romance, and she puts aside her own desires so as not to harm Serena. Roa is an honest, principled person (even though she had to tell a white lie about being engaged to Ned so that Andy would discontinue his advances and his betrayal of Serena). Note that the older nurse, Miss Perkins, isn't married - she's the archetypal career nurse spinster who has sacrificed marriage and family for her work - maybe she just wasn't pretty enough to snag a doctor or a rich patient! And so the stereotypes unfold. Roa in this story falls in love with her patient, and the doctor falls in love with his patient, so it seems this phenomenon afflicts the wider medical profession. If you're single and a patient, watch out! In the beginning, though, the doctor was hoping the nurse would fall in love with him. The female nurse is the male doctor's assistant and subordinate. Nurses are mostly pretty, young, white women, who work at the bedside in hospitals or for private patients, and who accept orders from male doctors. Otherwise they are older, not so pretty, white women who never got it together to get married and have kids, and who still have to take orders from male doctors.